Choosing and Using Anal Toys for Beginners: Your First Steps

Why Are Anal Toys a Good Starting Point for Beginners?

Anal toys allow you to control the size, depth, and speed, rather than jumping straight into penetrative play with a partner. You can experiment solo or with someone else, pause whenever you want, and find out which sensations actually suit your body.

The area around the anus is packed with sensitive nerves, so even gentle pressure on the outside can feel unexpectedly good. Internal play can create a sense of fullness, and curved toys may provide focused prostate stimulation for those with a prostate.

Anal play isn’t limited by gender, relationship type, or sexuality. It’s simply another way to enjoy pleasure—some people love it, others don’t. Curiosity is reason enough to give it a go, but there’s never any obligation to continue if it’s not for you.

For couples, starting out with a toy can make it easier to communicate. The person receiving can direct the action, control how deep the toy goes, and say exactly when to pause.

Which Anal Toy Should You Try First?

A small, tapered butt plug is often the most straightforward first anal toy, as it’s easy to insert and doesn’t need to be moved constantly.

Choose one with a slim, rounded tip, a gentle increase in width, a narrow neck, and a wide base that stays outside the body. Once the widest part is in comfortably, you can leave the plug in place and get used to the feeling.

Beginner plugs are generally simpler to use than toys meant for thrusting. They let you relax, breathe, and decide if you want to continue, without turning things into a performance.

You can check out the anal plug range, or browse our full sex toys for beginners collection.

A quick tip: Only use toys designed for anal play. A proper flared base or secure handle is vital, as it stops the toy from slipping fully inside.

How Do You Pick the Right Size, Shape, and Material?

Go for a toy with a small insertable width, a smooth, tapered shape, and a body-safe material with clear cleaning guidelines. The best first toy isn’t the flashiest—it’s the one that lets you stay comfortable and in control.

Check the actual insertable width, not just labels like ‘small’ or ‘beginner’. Product names can sound promising, but measurements tell you what you’re really working with.

A gently tapered toy is usually easier to insert than one with a blunt tip or sudden changes in width. The surface should be smooth, free from seams or rough edges.

Soft silicone is a favourite for beginners, as it’s flexible and less intimidating than hard glass or metal. Always pick toys with clear material listings and cleaning instructions, and avoid anything vaguely labelled as jelly or soft rubber.

A handy checklist for your first toy:

• Small insertable width
• Smooth, rounded tip
• Gentle taper
• Wide, stable base
• Clearly labelled body-safe materials
• Straightforward cleaning instructions

Don’t use household items or makeshift toys. They aren’t designed for safe removal, may have sharp or porous surfaces, and could break at the worst possible moment.

What Should You Have Ready Before Using an Anal Toy?

You’ll need a suitable toy, plenty of lubricant, clean hands, and enough private time so you’re not rushed. If you’re playing with a partner, have an honest chat before you get started.

An anal douche can be used as part of your prep if it helps you feel more at ease. It’s not essential for anal play, and a standard shower with gentle external washing is usually fine.

If you do use one, stick to the instructions, use lukewarm water, and keep things gentle. Overdoing it can cause irritation, so in this case, less is often more.

The anus doesn’t produce its own lubrication, so lube is a must. Water-based lubricants are the easiest for beginners, as they’re safe with most toys and condoms.

Silicone-based lubes last longer but might not suit every silicone toy. Always check the product details before mixing the two. You’ll find options in our personal lubricants range.

Apply lube to both the toy and the anal opening. Keep the bottle handy, as topping up is completely normal. There’s no prize for using just one squeeze.

If you’re with a partner, agree on simple cues like “slower”, “hold there”, or “stop”. The person receiving should always control the pace, depth, and whether to continue.

Comfort tip: Avoid numbing creams or sprays. Pain or discomfort are important signals—listen to them, add more lube, change position, or stop if needed.

How Can You Use Your First Anal Toy Comfortably?

Begin when you’re feeling relaxed and turned on, use lots of lube, and introduce the toy slowly. The aim is a comfortable experience, not to reach a certain depth or prove anything.

Start with gentle touch around the anus. A soft massage with a lubricated finger can help you get used to the sensation before inserting a toy.

When you’re ready, rest the tapered tip against the opening without pushing straight away. Breathe deeply, and as you exhale, apply gentle, steady pressure. If your muscles tense up, pause or move the toy away a bit.

Once the widest part of the plug is in comfortably, the narrow neck should settle naturally, with the base staying fully outside.

You might notice some pressure, fullness, or stretching at first. If you feel sharp pain, burning, numbness, or growing discomfort, stop. Add more lube, return to external play, or try again another day.

Keep your first go short and relaxed. A few comfortable minutes are more valuable than wearing a toy for ages just because someone online said so.

For a more detailed guide to prep, communication, and playing with a partner, check out the anal sex beginners guide.

How Do You Remove an Anal Toy Safely?

Take your time removing an anal toy—go just as slowly and gently as you did inserting it. Add more lube around the opening, relax, and carefully ease the toy out while breathing steadily.

Never yank a toy out, especially with anal beads. Each bead passes through the sensitive opening separately, which is part of the sensation but also why you should keep things slow and controlled.

For a butt plug, grip the base firmly and use slow, gentle movements. If your muscles tense, pause halfway and wait.

During partnered play, the person wearing the toy should stay in charge of removal. Surprises are great for parties, not when someone’s using an anal toy.

How Should You Clean and Store Anal Toys?

Wash your toy before and after every use, dry it thoroughly, and keep it in a clean pouch or separate container.

For most non-vibrating silicone toys, warm water and mild, fragrance-free soap work well. Vibrating toys may have different waterproof ratings, so always check the manufacturer’s care instructions.

Pay close attention to seams, textured spots, and where the toy joins its base. Rinse off all soap and let the toy dry completely before storing.

Never move a toy straight from the anus to the vagina. Clean it thoroughly first, or change the condom on the toy. This helps avoid spreading bacteria.

If more than one person is using the same toy, use a new condom for each partner and make sure the condom, lube, and toy material are all compatible.

Privacy and trust note: Orders from Desirel.co.uk arrive in plain packaging, with secure payment and reliable delivery. Your parcel won’t give away what you’re planning for the weekend.

What Are the Most Common Beginner Mistakes to Avoid?

The biggest mistakes are picking a toy that’s too big, not using enough lube, and moving faster than your body can handle.

Here are some common first-timer pitfalls:

• Choosing by looks without checking the actual size
• Using a toy without a proper flared base
• Skipping warm-up and external touch
• Not using enough lubricant
• Going deeper or faster without checking in
• Using numbing products to mask discomfort
• Using silicone lube on a silicone toy without checking compatibility
• Transferring a toy from anus to vagina without cleaning
• Trying to copy the size, speed, or intensity you see in porn

Adult films are made to look exciting on camera. They don’t show the prep, communication, breaks, or slow build-up that happen behind the scenes.

Feeling awkward, laughing, or changing your mind are all completely normal. Pain is not a rite of passage. If something feels wrong, stop, and seek medical advice if you experience ongoing pain, bleeding, or discomfort after play.

Anal Toys for Beginners: Frequently Asked Questions

Which Anal Toy Is Easiest for Someone New to Anal Play?

A small silicone butt plug with a tapered tip and a wide, flared base is usually the most beginner-friendly. It’s easy to control, doesn’t need constant movement, and lets you get used to the feeling of fullness at your own pace.

Are Anal Beads a Good Option for Beginners?

Small, flexible anal beads can work for beginners, but they involve more movement than a plug. Insert and remove each bead slowly, one at a time. For absolute beginners, a small tapered plug is often easier.

How Much Lube Should You Use for Anal Play?

Use enough lubricant to thoroughly coat both the toy and the anal opening. Everything should stay slick and comfortable throughout. Pause and reapply whenever things start to feel dry or less smooth.

Is It Safe to Use Silicone Lube with Silicone Toys?

Not always. Some silicone lubricants can damage certain silicone toys. Always check the manufacturer’s advice before using them together. If you’re unsure, stick with water-based lube.

How Long Should a Beginner Wear a Butt Plug?

Keep your first session short and focus on how your body feels, not the clock. A few comfortable minutes is plenty. Remove the plug if you feel pain, numbness, irritation, or increasing discomfort.

Can Couples Use Anal Toys for Beginners Together?

Absolutely. Let the receiving partner set the pace and depth, agree on clear signals, and avoid any sudden moves. If you’re interested in strap-on play, check out our beginner pegging guide.

How Can You Progress Without Rushing Things?

The best way to move forward is to repeat what felt good, rather than jumping to a bigger toy. Stick with the same size until insertion, wearing, and removal feel easy and predictable.

Later on, you might want to try a slightly larger plug, gentle vibrations, small anal beads, or focused prostate play. Change just one thing at a time so you can tell what your body actually enjoys.

Anal toys for beginners are meant to make exploring feel inviting, not overwhelming. Start small, choose a secure flared base, use plenty of lube, and let comfort lead the way.

Browse our sex toys for beginners and pick your first toy with clear product details, discreet delivery, and no pressure to hurry.

Desirel.co.uk Sex Shop